Current:Home > FinanceMeghan Markle Scores Legal Victory in Sister Samantha's Defamation Case-LoTradeCoin
Meghan Markle Scores Legal Victory in Sister Samantha's Defamation Case
View Date:2024-12-24 08:12:03
Meghan Markle's estranged half-sister Samantha Markle has lost her defamation case against the Duchess of Sussex.
On March 30, a Florida judge granted Meghan's motion to dismiss the lawsuit's claims without prejudice, according to court documents obtained by E! News.
Samantha, 58, alleged in her 2022 filing that several defamatory comments about her were published in Carolyn Durand and Omid Scobie's 2020 book Finding Freedom: Harry and Meghan and the Making of a Modern Royal Family. The unauthorized biography about Meghan and husband Prince Harry contains a chapter titled "A Problem Like Samantha."
Samantha also accused the duchess of making more defamatory statements about her in the couple's 2021 CBS interview with Oprah Winfrey. She noted in her lawsuit how Meghan, 41, told the TV personality, "I grew up as an only child, which everyone who grew up around me knows, and I wished I had siblings."
In her filing, Samantha—who shares father Thomas Markle with Meghan—stated that the alleged "defamatory statements" caused her irreparable prejudice, injury, and harm to her reputation, as well as anxiety and emotional distress. She also said she received hate mail, ongoing negative press, and was stalked by one of Meghan's fans.
In his ruling dismissing all allegations, the judge stated that Samantha's "claims based on Finding Freedom will be dismissed with prejudice, as [she] cannot plausibly allege that [Meghan] published the book, and amendment of these claims would be futile."
With regard to Meghan's "only child" comments in the Oprah interview, the judge ruled, "As a reasonable listener would understand it, [Meghan] merely expresses an opinion about her childhood and her relationship with her half-siblings. Thus, the Court finds that [her] statement is not objectively verifiable or subject to empirical proof."
In his ruling, the judge also found that two other alleged defamatory statements Samantha claimed Meghan made to Oprah were not actually found in the interview transcript. The duchess' sister, he noted, "does more than paraphrase [Meghan's] words—she substantively changes the meaning of what was said."
Meanwhile, Samantha can file an amended complaint regarding claims related to the Oprah interview within 14 days, the judge ruled, and she plans to do so.
"This upcoming amendment will address certain legal issues that are related to our claims for defamation as it specifically relates to the Oprah interview on CBS," her attorney, Jamie A. Sasson, told E! News in a statement March 31, adding that they "look forward to presenting an even stronger argument for the defamation and losses that our client has had to endure."
Samantha's lawsuit comes after several years of criticizing Meghan and Harry publicly. This includes comparing the duchess to the Disney villain Cruella de Vil on Twitter just a few months after Harry and Meghan's 2018 wedding—which Samantha was not invited to—and publishing a memoir in 2021 that refers to Meghan as "Princess Pushy."
For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News AppveryGood! (777)
Related
- Tony Todd, star of 'Candyman,' 'Final Destination,' dies at 69
- They had the same name. The same childhood cancer. They lost touch – then reunited.
- San Diego Zoo will receive two new giant pandas from China after nearly all pandas in U.S. were returned
- In unusual push, funders band together to get out grants around election work ‘early’
- BITFII Introduce
- Prince Harry and Meghan to visit Nigeria to talk Invictus Games
- Trump hush money trial continues as prosecution calls Michael Cohen's banker | The Excerpt
- Tony Awards: Which Broadway shows are eligible for nominations? When is the 2024 show?
- Blake Shelton Announces New Singing Competition Show After Leaving The Voice
- Beat The Heat With ban.do's 30% Off Sale, And Shop More Bestsellers Up to 52% Off
Ranking
- 'Serial swatter': 18-year-old pleads guilty to making nearly 400 bomb threats, mass shooting calls
- U.S. Soccer, Mexico will submit joint bid for 2031 Women's World Cup instead of 2027
- HBCU Xavier of New Orleans moves closer to establishing a medical school
- 4 law enforcement officers killed in shooting in Charlotte, North Carolina
- Detroit-area police win appeal over liability in death of woman in custody
- Paramount CEO Bob Bakish to step down amid sale discussions
- Cowboys and running back Ezekiel Elliott reuniting after agreeing to deal, AP source says
- Why Bhad Bhabie Is Warning Against Facial Fillers After Dissolving Them
Recommendation
-
New York eyes reviving congestion pricing toll before Trump takes office
-
3 US Marshals task force members killed while serving warrant in North Carolina, authorities say
-
These Mean Girls Secrets Totally Are Fetch
-
Jill Duggar Shares Unseen Baby Bump Photos After Daughter Isla Marie's Stillbirth
-
RHOP's Candiace Dillard Bassett Gives Birth, Shares First Photos of Baby Boy
-
USA TODAY's investigative story on Mel Tucker wins Headliner Award. Tucker was later fired.
-
Remote Lake Superior island wolf numbers are stable but moose population declining, researchers say
-
What does conditioner do? Here’s how to attain soft, silky hair.